Case details

Court: ca3
Docket #: 12-1150
Case Name: Drake v. Filko
PACER case #: 12-1150
Date filed: 01/24/2012
Date terminated: 07/31/2013
Nature of Suit: 3440 Other Civil Rights

Documents

Date Filed Document # Attachment # Short Description Long Description Upload date SHA1 hash
01/24/2012 003010786297 0 CIVIL CASE DOCKETED. Notice filed by Appellants Assn of New Jersey Rifle & Pistol Clubs Inc, John M. Drake, Finley Fenton, Gregory C. Gallaher, Daniel J. Piszczatoski, Lenny S. Salerno and Second Amendment Foundation Inc in District Court No. 2-10-cv-06110. (TMK)
01/26/2012 003010789883 0 ECF FILER: ENTRY OF APPEARANCE from Mary E. Wood on behalf of Respondent(s) Hon. Rudolph A. Filko, Hon. Edward A. Jerejian, Hon. Thomas A. Manahan, Col. Rick fuentes, Attorney General Chiesa. (MEW)
01/27/2012 003010791785 0 ECF FILER: CIVIL INFORMATION STATEMENT on behalf of Appellants Assn of New Jersey Rifle & Pistol Clubs Inc, John M. Drake, Finley Fenton, Gregory C. Gallaher, Daniel J. Piszczatoski, Lenny S. Salerno and Second Amendment Foundation Inc, filed. (DDJ)
01/27/2012 003010791791 0 ECF FILER: Concise Summary of the Case filed by Appellants Assn of New Jersey Rifle & Pistol Clubs Inc, John M. Drake, Finley Fenton, Gregory C. Gallaher, Daniel J. Piszczatoski, Lenny S. Salerno and Second Amendment Foundation Inc, received. (DDJ)
01/27/2012 003010791816 0 ECF FILER: ENTRY OF APPEARANCE from David D. Jensen on behalf of Appellant(s) Daniel J. Piszczatoski, John M. Drake, Greg Gallaher, Lenny S. Salerno, Finley Fenton, Second Amendment Foundation, Inc., Association of New Jersey Rifle & Pistol Clubs, Inc.. (DDJ)
01/27/2012 003010791823 0 ECF FILER: DISCLOSURE STATEMENT on behalf of Appellant Second Amendment Foundation Inc, filed. (DDJ)
01/27/2012 003010791826 0 ECF FILER: DISCLOSURE STATEMENT on behalf of Appellant Assn of New Jersey Rifle & Pistol Clubs Inc, filed. (DDJ)
02/13/2012 003010807314 0 FOLLOW UP LETTER to David D. Jensen, Esq. for Jeffrey M. Muller and Gregory A. Spellmeyer, Esq. for Rudolph A. Filko, Philip Maenza, Attorney General New Jersey, Superintendent New Jersey State Police, Edward A. Jerejian and Thomas V. Manahan, Esq. requesting the following document(s): Appearance Form on or before 02/27/2012. (TMK)
02/13/2012 003010807748 0 ECF FILER: NOT PARTICIPATING: David D. Jensen, Esq. for Assn of New Jersey Rifle & Pistol Clubs Inc, Daniel J. Piszczatoski, John M. Drake, Gregory C. Gallaher, Lenny S. Salerno, Finley Fenton, Second Amendment Foundation Inc and Jeffrey M. Muller Appellee Jeffrey M. Muller will not participate in this appeal, received. [This document will be SENT TO THE MERITS PANEL if/when applicable] (DDJ)
02/27/2012 003010819809 0 ECF FILER: Transcript Purchase Order Form (Part 1) filed by Appellants Assn of New Jersey Rifle & Pistol Clubs Inc, John M. Drake, Finley Fenton, Gregory C. Gallaher, Daniel J. Piszczatoski, Lenny S. Salerno and Second Amendment Foundation Inc advising this court that transcripts are not needed. (DDJ)
02/27/2012 003010820137 0 BRIEFING NOTICE ISSUED. Brief on behalf of Appellants Assn of New Jersey Rifle & Pistol Clubs Inc, John M. Drake, Finley Fenton, Gregory C. Gallaher, Daniel J. Piszczatoski, Lenny S. Salerno, Second Amendment Foundation Inc due on or before 04/09/2012. Appendix due on or before 04/09/2012. (TMK)
03/13/2012 003010836058 0 ECF FILER: ENTRY OF APPEARANCE from Daniela Ivancikova on behalf of Appellee(s) Rudolph A. Filko, Edward A. Jerejian, Superintendent New Jersey State Police, Attorney General of New Jersey, Thomas V. Manahan, Esq.. (DI)
04/09/2012 003010863289 0 ECF FILER: ELECTRONIC BRIEF with Volume I of Appendix attached on behalf of Appellants Association of New Jersey Rifle and Pistol Clubs Inc, John M. Drake, Finley Fenton, Gregory C. Gallaher, Daniel J. Piszczatoski, Lenny S. Salerno and Second Amendment Foundation Inc, filed. Certificate of Service dated 04/09/2012 by US mail, ECF. (DDJ)
04/09/2012 003010863295 0 ECF FILER: ELECTRONIC APPENDIX on behalf of Appellants Association of New Jersey Rifle and Pistol Clubs Inc, John M. Drake, Finley Fenton, Gregory C. Gallaher, Daniel J. Piszczatoski, Lenny S. Salerno and Second Amendment Foundation Inc, filed. Certificate of service dated 04/09/2012 by ECF, US mail. (DDJ)
04/09/2012 003010863309 0 ECF FILER: ELECTRONIC APPENDIX on behalf of Appellants Association of New Jersey Rifle and Pistol Clubs Inc, John M. Drake, Finley Fenton, Gregory C. Gallaher, Daniel J. Piszczatoski, Lenny S. Salerno and Second Amendment Foundation Inc, filed. Certificate of service dated 04/09/2012 by US mail, ECF. (DDJ)
04/19/2012 003010874130 0 NON COMPLIANCE Order issued to Appellants Association of New Jersey Rifle and Pistol Clubs Inc, John M. Drake, Finley Fenton, Gregory C. Gallaher, Daniel J. Piszczatoski, Lenny S. Salerno and Second Amendment Foundation Inc regarding the brief filed on 04/09/2012. Please open the attachment for the full text of the Order. Compliance due by 04/23/2012. (EMA)
04/24/2012 003010878397 0 ECF FILER: ELECTRONIC ADDENDUM to BRIEF on behalf of Appellants Association of New Jersey Rifle and Pistol Clubs Inc, John M. Drake, Finley Fenton, Gregory C. Gallaher, Daniel J. Piszczatoski, Lenny S. Salerno and Second Amendment Foundation Inc containing an Amended Table of Authorities and Certification of Identity, filed. Certificate of Service dated 04/24/2012 by US mail. [Entry edited to reflect contents]--[Edited 04/27/2012 by EMA] (DDJ)
05/21/2012 003010905280 0 ECF FILER: Motion filed by Appellees Attorney General New Jersey, Rudolph A. Filko, Edward A. Jerejian, Thomas V. Manahan, Esq. and Superintendent New Jersey State Police for Extension of Time to file Brief until/for 30 days. Certificate of Service dated 05/21/2012. (DI)
05/21/2012 003010905903 0 ORDER (Clerk) granting Motion for extension of time to file brief by Appellees Attorney General New Jersey, Superintendent New Jersey State Police, Rudolph A. Filko, Edward A. Jerejian and Thomas V. Manahan, Esq. until June 28, 2012, filed. (TMK)
06/28/2012 003010942873 0 ECF FILER: ENTRY OF APPEARANCE from Robert Lougy, AAG on behalf of Appellee(s) THE HON. RUDOLPH A. FILKO, in his Official Capacity as Judge of the Superior Court of Passaic County; THE HON. EDWARD A. JEREJIAN, in his Official Capacity as Judge of the Superior Court of Bergen County; THE HON. THOMAS A. MANAHAN, in his Official Capaci. (RTL)
06/28/2012 003010942906 0 ECF FILER: ELECTRONIC BRIEF with addendum attached on behalf of Appellees Attorney General New Jersey, Rudolph A. Filko, Edward A. Jerejian, Thomas V. Manahan, Esq. and Superintendent New Jersey State Police, filed. Certificate of Service dated 06/28/2012 by ECF. (Docket text edited by the Office fo the Cerlk to include addendum information. ) -- Edited 06/28/2012 by LAL] (MEW)
06/28/2012 003010943123 0 ECF FILER: LETTER from Attorney Daniela Ivancikova, Esq. for Appellees Rudolph A. Filko, Attorney General New Jersey, Superintendent New Jersey State Police, Edward A. Jerejian and Thomas V. Manahan, Esq. Letter withdrawing as Attorney of Record. Certificate of Service dated 06/28/2012. (DI)
07/05/2012 003010948989 0 ECF FILER: ENTRY OF APPEARANCE from Adam K. Levin on behalf of Amicus Curiae THE BRADY CENTER TO PREVENT GUN VIOLENCE, CEASEFIRE NJ, INTERNATIONAL BROTHERHOOD OF POLICE OFFICERS, MAJOR CITIES CHIEFS ASSOCIATION, NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF WOMEN LAW ENFORCEMENT EXECUTIVES, NEW JERSEY MILLION MOM MARCH CHAPTERS, POLICE FOUNDATION. (AKL)
07/05/2012 003010949010 0 ECF FILER: ELECTRONIC AMICUS/INTERVENOR BRIEF on behalf of THE BRADY CENTER TO PREVENT GUN VIOLENCE, CEASEFIRE NJ, INTERNATIONAL BROTHERHOOD OF POLICE OFFICERS, MAJOR CITIES CHIEFS ASSOCIATION, NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF WOMEN LAW ENFORCEMENT EXECUTIVES, NEW JERSEY MILLION MOM MARCH CHAPTERS, POLICE FOUNDATION in support of Appellee/Respondent, filed. Certificate of Service dated 07/05/2012 by ECF. (AKL)
07/09/2012 003010951012 0 ECF FILER: ELECTRONIC ADDENDUM to BRIEF on behalf of Amicus Appellees Brady Center to Prevent Gun Violence, Ceasefire NJ, International Brotherhood of Police Officers., Major Cities Cheifs Association, National Association of Women Law Enforcement Executives, New Jersey Million Mom March and Police Foundation , filed. Certificate of Service dated 07/09/2012 by ECF. (AKL)
07/30/2012 003010972952 0 ECF FILER: ELECTRONIC REPLY BRIEF on behalf of Appellants Association of New Jersey Rifle and Pistol Clubs Inc, John M. Drake, Finley Fenton, Gregory C. Gallaher, Daniel J. Piszczatoski, Lenny S. Salerno and Second Amendment Foundation Inc, filed. Certificate of Service dated 07/30/2012 by US mail. (DDJ)
08/02/2012 003010976532 0 NON COMPLIANCE Order issued to Appellants Association of New Jersey Rifle and Pistol Clubs Inc, John M. Drake, Finley Fenton, Gregory C. Gallaher, Daniel J. Piszczatoski, Lenny S. Salerno and Second Amendment Foundation Inc regarding the hard copies of the reply brief received on 08/2/2012. Please open the attachment for the full text of the Order. Compliance due by 08/06/2012. [Text edited]--[Edited 08/02/2012 by EAF] (EAF)
10/02/2012 003011033744 0 ECF FILER: Request by Appellants Association of New Jersey Rifle and Pistol Clubs Inc, John M. Drake, Finley Fenton, Gregory C. Gallaher, Daniel J. Piszczatoski, Lenny S. Salerno and Second Amendment Foundation Inc for Oral Argument. [SEND TO MERITS] (DDJ)
11/02/2012 003011065123 0 Calendared for Tuesday, 02/12/2013. (TLW)
11/05/2012 003011066234 0 ECF FILER: ENTRY OF APPEARANCE from Alan Gura on behalf of Appellant(s) Daniel Pisczcatoski, John Drake, Gregory Gallaher, Lenny Salerno, Finley Fenton, Second Amendment Foundation, Inc., Association of New Jersey Rifle and Pistol Clubs, Inc.. (AG)
11/05/2012 003011067716 0 ECF FILER: ARGUMENT ACKNOWLEDGMENT filed by Attorney Mary E. Wood, Esq. for Appellees Rudolph A. Filko, Attorney General New Jersey, Superintendent New Jersey State Police, Edward A. Jerejian and Thomas V. Manahan, Esq.. Certificate of Service dated 11/05/2012. (MEW)
11/06/2012 003011068593 0 ECF FILER: ARGUMENT ACKNOWLEDGMENT filed by Attorney Alan Gura, Esq. for Appellants Association of New Jersey Rifle and Pistol Clubs Inc, Daniel J. Piszczatoski, John M. Drake, Gregory C. Gallaher, Lenny S. Salerno, Finley Fenton and Second Amendment Foundation Inc. Certificate of Service dated 11/06/2012. (AG)
11/07/2012 003011070106 0 ECF FILER: Certificate of Service filed by Attorney Mary E. Wood, Esq. for Appellees Rudolph A. Filko, Attorney General New Jersey, Superintendent New Jersey State Police, Edward A. Jerejian and Thomas V. Manahan, Esq. Certificate of Service dated 11/05/2012.--[Edited 11/14/2012 by TLW] (MEW)
01/16/2013 003011137518 0 CLERK'S LETTER to counsel written at the direction of the Court. The Court observes that since the parties submitted their briefs, the Courts of Appeal for the Second and Seventh Circuits have issued decisions that potentially bear on the issues presented in this case. See Moore v. Madigan, --- F.3d ---, 2012 WL 6156062, at *1 (7th Cir. Dec. 11, 2012); Kachalsky v. Cnty. of Westchester, 701 F.3d 81 (2d Cir. 2012). The Court hereby orders the parties to file supplemental briefs addressing these decisions. The briefs shall not exceed ten double-spaced pages and are to be filed not later than Monday, January 28, 2013. (TLW)
01/25/2013 003011146388 0 Oral Argument Notification for Tuesday, 02/12/2013. (TLW) 2013-07-14 08:05:24 b14d7a098c358ac8908b08fc13797b8849ee2ab3
01/28/2013 003011148550 0 ECF FILER: ELECTRONIC SUPPLEMENTAL BRIEF on behalf of Appellants Association of New Jersey Rifle and Pistol Clubs Inc, John M. Drake, Finley Fenton, Gregory C. Gallaher, Daniel J. Piszczatoski, Lenny S. Salerno and Second Amendment Foundation Inc, filed. Certificate of Service dated 01/28/2013 by ECF. (AG)
01/28/2013 003011149248 0 ECF FILER: ELECTRONIC SUPPLEMENTAL BRIEF on behalf of Appellees Attorney General New Jersey, Rudolph A. Filko, Edward A. Jerejian, Thomas V. Manahan, Esq. and Superintendent New Jersey State Police, filed. Certificate of Service dated 01/28/2013 by ECF. (MEW)
01/28/2013 003011149306 0 ECF FILER: ELECTRONIC SUPPLEMENTAL AMICUS/INTERVENOR BRIEF on behalf of Amicus Appellees Brady Center to Prevent Gun Violence, Ceasefire New Jersey, International Brotherhood of Police Officers., Major Cities Cheifs Association, National Association of Women Law Enforcement Executives, New Jersey Million Mom March and Police Foundation in support of Appellee/Respondent, filed. Certificate of Service dated 01/28/2013 by ECF.--[Edited 01/29/2013 by MS] (AKL)
02/12/2013 003011164728 0 CLERK'S LETTER to counsel written at the direction of the Court. During argument today, the Court directed counsel to file a transcript of oral argument. The transcript of oral argument is to be filed no later than Tuesday, February 26, 2013 in the above-entitled case(s). Liaison counsel should immediately advise the Clerk’s Office of the court reporter or agency handling the transcription of oral argument. At the direction of the Court, the costs should be shared equally between the parties. (Please see the Attached Letter for Full Text.) (TLW)
02/26/2013 003011177444 0 ECF FILER: Transcript of oral argument on 02/12/2013 prepared at the direction of the Court. (DDJ)
02/26/2013 003011178204 0 ECF FILER: Certificate of Service filed by Appellants Association of New Jersey Rifle and Pistol Clubs Inc, John M. Drake, Finley Fenton, Gregory C. Gallaher, Daniel J. Piszczatoski, Lenny S. Salerno and Second Amendment Foundation Inc. Certificate of Service dated 02/26/2013. (DDJ)
02/27/2013 003011179434 0 ECF FILER: LETTER filed by Appellees Attorney General New Jersey, Rudolph A. Filko, Edward A. Jerejian, Thomas V. Manahan, Esq. in accordance to the Court's request at argument. Certificate of Service dated 02/27/2013 by ECF. [Event edited by Clerk's Office.]--[Edited 02/28/2013 by TLW] (MEW)
02/28/2013 003011180381 0 ECF FILER: Motion filed by Appellees Attorney General New Jersey, Rudolph A. Filko, Edward A. Jerejian, Thomas V. Manahan, Esq. and Superintendent New Jersey State Police for Leave to file its Supplemental Letter As Requested By the Court As Within Time. Certificate of Service dated 02/28/2013.--[Edited 02/28/2013 by TLW] (MEW)
03/04/2013 003011182921 0 ECF FILER: ELECTRONIC SUPPLEMENTAL BRIEF on behalf of Appellants Association of New Jersey Rifle and Pistol Clubs Inc, John M. Drake, Finley Fenton, Gregory C. Gallaher, Daniel J. Piszczatoski, Lenny S. Salerno and Second Amendment Foundation Inc, filed. Certificate of Service dated 03/04/2013 by ECF. (AG)
03/04/2013 003011183584 0 ORDER (HARDIMAN, ALDISERT, Circuit Judges and *STARK, District Judge) granting Motion filed by Appellees Attorney General New Jersey, et al. for Leave to File Supplemental Letter of 02/27/2013 As Requested By the Court As Within Time, filed. Thomas M. Hardiman, Authoring Judge. *Hon. Leonard P. Stark, District Judge for the District Court of Delaware, sitting by designation. (TLW)
03/04/2013 003011183755 0 NON COMPLIANCE Order issued to Appellants Association of New Jersey Rifle and Pistol Clubs Inc, John M. Drake, Finley Fenton, Gregory C. Gallaher, Daniel J. Piszczatoski, Lenny S. Salerno and Second Amendment Foundation Inc regarding the supplemental brief filed on 03/04/2013. Please open the attachment for the full text of the Order. Compliance due by 03/07/2013. This Order does not change the deadline for filing the next brief. (EMA)
03/07/2013 003011187849 0 ECF FILER: Motion filed by Appellants Association of New Jersey Rifle and Pistol Clubs Inc, John M. Drake, Finley Fenton, Gregory C. Gallaher, Daniel J. Piszczatoski, Lenny S. Salerno and Second Amendment Foundation Inc for Leave to File Supplemental Brief in Response to Appellees Letter-Brief. Certificate of Service dated 03/07/2012. [Entry edited to reflect the correct relief requested]--[Edited 03/07/2013 by EMA] (DDJ)
03/08/2013 003011189783 0 ORDER (HARDIMAN, ALDISERT, Circuit Judges and STARK, District Judge) The foregoing Motion by Appellants for leave to file supplemental brief in response to Appellees letter-brief is granted, filed. Hardiman, Authoring Judge. (EMA)
04/02/2013 003011216043 0 ECF FILER: LETTER MOTION from Attorney Alan Gura, Esq. for Appellant Piszczatoski titled Suggestion of Partial Mootness, filed. Certificate of Service dated 04/02/2013.--[Edited 04/03/2013 by TMK] (AG)
04/10/2013 003011223824 0 ORDER (HARDIMAN, Authoring Judge and ALDISERT, Circuit Judges and *STARK, District Court Judge) granting motion to withdraw appeal by Daniel Piszczatoski and the caption is re-styled "Drake v Filko", filed. *Hon. Leonard P. Stark, Distric Judge for the District Court of Delaware, sitting by designation. (TMK)
04/10/2013 003011223878 0 ORDER (Clerk) In light of the Court's order dismissing Piszczatoski and upon further review of the current caption, the caption is amended as follows: JOHN M. DRAKE; GREGORY C. GALLAGHER;LENNY S. SALERNO; FINLEY FENTON; SECOND AMENDMENT FOUNDATION, INC.; ASSOCIATION OF NEW JERSEY RIFLE & PISTOL CLUBS, INC, Appellants v. THE HON. RUDOLPH A. FILKO, in his Official Capacity as Judge of the Superior Court of Passaic County; HON. EDWARD A. JEREJIAN, in his Official Capacity as Judge of the Superior Court of Bergen County; THE HON. THOMAS V. MANAHAN, in his Official Capacity as Judge of the Superior Court of Morris County; SUPERINTENDENT NEW JERSEY STATE POLICE; CHIEF RICHARD COOK, in his Official Capacity as Chief of the Montville, New Jersey Police Department; ATTORNEY GENERAL OF NEW JERSEY; ROBERT JONES, in his official capacity as Chief of the Hammonton, New Jersey Police Department , filed. (TMK) 2013-05-02 19:04:23 5587841f5d6a0f514f5fa359769c3a89e9036361
07/31/2013 003011341807 0 PRECEDENTIAL OPINION Coram: HARDIMAN and ALDISERT, Authoring and Circuit Judges and *STARK, District Court Judge. Total Pages: 72. With dissenting opinion by Judge Hardiman. *The Honorable Leonard P. Stark, Judge of the United States District Court for the District of Deleware, sitting by designation.--[Edited 08/15/2013 by TMK] (TMK) 2013-08-03 21:34:35 dd2ab35a30239b66dbb20800563348bb97e04dab
07/31/2013 003011341810 0 JUDGMENT Affirmed. Costs taxed against Appellants. (TMK)
003011341810 1 Judgment Entered
003011341810 2 Notice of Judgment
08/14/2013 003011358321 0 ECF FILER: Petition filed by Appellants Association of New Jersey Rifle and Pistol Clubs Inc, John M. Drake, Finley Fenton, Gregory C. Gallaher, Lenny S. Salerno and Second Amendment Foundation Inc for Rehearing before original panel and the court en banc. Certificate of Service dated 08/14/2013. (DDJ)
003011358321 1 Petition for Rehearing by the Court En Banc 2013-08-15 10:43:54 e63670e93b9ba94873ad41e53cdaa4e2b3f08bed
003011358321 2 Decision
003011358321 3 Judgment
08/27/2013 003011371451 0 ORDER (MCKEE, Chief Judge, RENDELL, AMBRO, FUENTES, SMITH, FISHER, JORDAN, HARDIMAN, GREENAWAY JR., VANASKIE, SHWARTZ, *ALDISERT, Authoring and Circuit Judgesand **STARK, District Court Judge) denying Petition En Banc Rehearing by Appellants Association of New Jersey Rifle and Pistol Clubs Inc, John M. Drake, Gregory C. Gallaher, Lenny S. Salerno, Finley Fenton and Second Amendment Foundation Inc; denying Petition for Panel Rehearing filed by Appellants Association of New Jersey Rifle and Pistol Clubs Inc, John M. Drake, Gregory C. Gallaher, Lenny S. Salerno, Finley Fenton and Second Amendment Foundation Inc. Judges Ambro, Fisher, Jordan and Hardiman have voted for rehearing en banc, filed. * The vote of Honorable Ruggero J. Aldisert is limited to panel rehearing. **The vote of Honorable Leonard P. Stark, District Judge for the District of Deleware is limited to panel rehearing.--[Edited 08/27/2013 by TMK] (TMK) 2013-08-29 21:56:56 cfa9f881a4459af0bb6e1c46f7cff00d4d65db77
09/04/2013 003011377368 0 MANDATE ISSUED, filed. (TMK)
003011377368 1 Mandate Issued
003011377368 2 Opinion
003011377368 3 Mandate Letter